Sally's Apizza
An iconic Wooster Street pizzeria opened in 1938, famous for its Fresh Tomato White Pie and Potato & Rosemary Pizza.
Opened in 1938 on the same Wooster Street as Frank Pepe, Sally's is one of New Haven's "Big Three" pizzerias. Food bloggers 2foodtrippers list it as their favorite, recommending the Fresh Tomato White Pie, Potato & Rosemary Pizza, and Mozzarella & Tomato Pie. Pizzas are baked to order, resulting in longer wait times; some guides note it takes about 30–45 minutes after ordering, and bloggers experienced a wait of about 30 minutes for a table, with draft beer and wine available in the outdoor waiting area. Wikipedia states they do not accept reservations, but official confirmation is pending. It has a Tripadvisor rating of around 3.7, lower than the other two, and about 3.8 on Yelp. Located about 1 km from downtown, it is easily walkable.
Opening hours
Mon–Thu 11:00–21:00; Fri–Sat 10:30–22:00; Sun 10:30–21:00 (Yelp Oct 2026, though some sources show closing an hour later)
Nearby sights
- Sally's Apizza
- Wooster Square
- Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
- New Haven Green
- Shubert Theatre
- Yale University Old Campus & Harkness Tower
- Louis' Lunch
- Beinecke Rare Book & Manuscript Library