McKenzie's Under the Bridge
McKenzie's Fresh Fish & Conch
A local stall at Potter's Cay Dock under the Paradise Island Bridge, repeatedly praised by diners for its made-to-order conch salad, considered one of the best on the island.
Located at Stall #1, Potter's Cay Dock on East Bay Street, right under the bridge leading to Paradise Island, it is about a 10-15 minute walk across the bridge from Atlantis. This is a working dock where fishing boats unload, so the environment is rustic, and the stall is small and hot inside. The conch salad comes in regular and tropical varieties and is freshly chopped only after you order; as of August 2026, diners still rated it as the best among the three nearby stalls. The conch fritters, cracked conch, snapper, and shrimp also receive good reviews. The downsides are slow service—some have waited nearly an hour—and they may sell out by evening. Some reviews also complain about the service attitude. It is recommended to visit during the day and double-check your change when paying.
Opening hours
No clear operating hours available; generally open from daytime until evening, closing when sold out
Nearby sights
- Potter's Cay
- Atlantis Paradise Island
- Cabbage Beach
- Versailles Gardens & French Cloister
- Queen's Staircase
- Fort Montagu
- Fort Fincastle
- Parliament Square