El Pueblito

Often rated the best Mexican restaurant in Muskoka, serving traditional Mexican food rather than American Tex-Mex.

Located at 155 Manitoba Street, it opened in 2009 and switched to traditional Mexican cooking in 2016, avoiding the Tex-Mex style. Signature dishes include hand-rolled chicken taquitos, charcoal-grilled beef burrito, mole poblano chicken, and fried shrimp and cheese quesadillas, served with freshly fried tortilla chips and salsa. The dining room is small, so book ahead for weekend dinners. Expect about CAD 20–30 per person. It is closed on Sundays and Mondays, and it's an easy walk from downtown.

Opening hours

Tuesday to Thursday 12:00–21:00; Friday and Saturday 12:00–21:30; closed Sunday and Monday

Mexican food · Local favorite

Nearby sights

Places to eat nearby

More in Muskoka Lakes